The Folly of Nuclear “Bet-the-Farm” Loan Guarantees

Congressman Dennis Kucinich decries 'Bet the Farm' loan guarantees for nuclear reactors. (photo: Mark Wilson Getty Images)
Congressman Dennis Kucinich decries ‘Bet the Farm’ loan guarantees for nuclear reactors. (photo: Mark Wilson Getty Images)

go to original article

By Dennis Kucinich, Beyond Nuclear

30 April 12

 

 

he Department of Energy is about to guarantee $8.3 Billion of loans to the Southern Company and its partners to build two new nuclear reactors in Georgia. That is 15 times the size of the loan guarantee to Solyndra, the solar energy company that failed last year.

How bad an investment is this nuclear loan guarantee?

Nuclear reactors are so bad an investment that Wall Street won’t touch them. Moody’s has called them “bet-the-farm-investments.” Moody’s has downgraded the financial ratings of the utilities that are planning to build them. Citibank says that “Three of the risks faced by developers – Construction, Power Price, and Operational – are so large and variable that individually they could each bring even the largest utility company to its knees financially.”

Even nuclear industry executives call new reactors “a large speculation” and say that they “are not economic” because of low gas prices, excess generating capacity and low growth in demand. Two of these executives have admitted that “We can’t make the numbers work.” The Economist magazine declared in its March 10th issue that nuclear power is “the dream that failed”–the plants are too costly and uncompetitive with alternatives.

Wind, solar and energy efficiency are all better investments, and their costs have been falling for years. So, why are we wasting $8.3 billion on corporate welfare to an industry that, for five continuous decades, has not been able to operate without large government subsidies?

_______________________

Comment: Bet your life, the whole life system.

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close